With free agency just days away I get so triggered with how many players are labeled “a top 5 player in the NBA“. There are like 9 different top 5 players.
So I’m giving the OFFICIAL Splittingtens NBA top 15 players ranking based on my limited knowledge of the NBA. I picked 15 because that’s where I felt the ELITE players ended. I’m basing this on having this player healthy for next year’s regular season (so they need to maintain team chemistry!) and playoffs.
- Kevin Durant – This is going to get shit on since Kawhi just pwned the NBA, but KD was better before he got hurt. He just was. I know health is part of the game, but if he stayed healthy, he’d have won his 3rd straight Finals MVP and everyone would be saying he’s the best player on the planet and Kawhi’s great but needs more help.
- Kawhi Leonard – You could obviously put Kawhi #1 and I wouldn’t argue much. He’s a great example of not needing to win the regular season and taking it to another level for the playoffs.
- Lebron James – This season was his first glimpse of being human. He’s still great, but his reign over the league as definitive #1 player has been taken in my opinion.
- Paul George – This will get poo-poo’d. Before his shoulder injury he was a legit contender for MVP this season. A monster on both ends and shooting the lights out from 3. Give him someone other than Russ and he can be the best player on a championship team.
- Steph Curry – Greatest shooter ever and I don’t blame him for the loss. He changed the league, but it’s starting to catch up to him. Not really, but a little bit. And he’s meh on defense.
- Giannis Antetokounmpo – Odd to put the MVP at 6 but he needs to be a little more polished from 3 and his inexperience showed a bit in the playoffs. He’ll get better though, and he dominates physically.
- Anthony Davis – Hard to gauge, especially in the playoffs, since he never had a great supporting cast and frankly I haven’t watched him that much, but routinely labeled a ‘top five player‘ by analysts. Not pumped he’ll be a Laker and I’ll be rooting against them this season.
- Damian Lillard – Over Harden?! Harden’s basically a slightly better version of Dame, but I’ll take the team chemistry and not relying on the refs giving you calls during the playoffs.
- James Harden – Can’t deny his scoring ability. But as I said above, his style doesn’t translate as well to the playoffs and he’s too much of a one-man-band.
- Nikola Jokic – I only really watched him play in the playoffs but he’s a stud big man. And he’s basically fat which is awesome. I think some would argue he should be higher.
- Joel Embiid – Arguably could be higher since I’m assuming he’s healthy, but shrunk at moments in the playoffs and he still has too many obvious flaws (turnovers, 3s) in his game to be truly top tier.
- Klay Thompson – Klay is hard to rank because he’s never been the best player on his team, and people will say this is too high, but I’m a Klay believer. Elite defender, ridiculous shooter.
- Kyrie Irving – He’s a nut and apparently hard to get along with, but he hits big shots and can finish around the rim as well as any player in the league.
- Russell Westbrook – I’ve been on the anti-Russ train for about 6 years now. He’d be near the top of the most-exciting-to-watch rankings, but his run of being a top player in the league is over, and the past two seasons (where he averaged a triple double!!) are proof.
- Karl Anthony Towns / Rudy Gobert – I don’t watch either of these guys play so I’m putting them together. Deal with it.
Honorable Mention: Oladipo, Butler, Draymond
So there it is. The OFFICIAL rankings. Argue all you want, but these are right.
Where the fuck is Marcus
I understand and respect your choices, but James Harden may be one of the best scorers of all time. He may slack on defense at times, but overall his defense is actually okay. George has no place in the top 5, sorry. Durant, Leonard, Lebron, Curry, Greek Freak, Harden, and arguably Davis are all more talented and provide more. I really don’t think George could take over a playoff series like any of the above players could. Well thought out list, though.
Prior to posting I knew my three biggest disagreements would be having George that high, Harden that low, and Russ that low (though people are now realizing Russ isn’t actually that good).
I’ve always been high on George. And I contemplated switching him and Giannis, but I really think if George is healthy and has the right parts around him, he’s top 5.
Harden is one of the few people that I felt differently about when I watched him in person. It was unreal, he could score whenever he wanted to. I just don’t think his style is conducive for playoff success, and yes, obviously the defense irks me.
Fair points. I was thinking back and George was the best player on a Pacers team that gave Lebron’s Heat teams a lot of problems in the playoffs, so I retract a bit of my statement regarding his playoff pedigree. Obviously he had an amazing season this year, especially considering the gruesome injury he suffered. I agree that Russ actually probably hurts his success more than it helps. I would love to see George paired with another superstar who can actually consistently make a jump shot. This year will say a lot about every superstar. I really hope Leonard doesn’t go to the Lakers because then I think the league will be wide open. Then the best man/team wins, injuries aside.